2 total
Costs of the appeal and related motions fixed at $45,000 on a partial indemnity scale.
The respondents sought costs of $77,362 for the motion for leave to appeal, the motion to expedite the appeals, and the appeals.
The Court of Appeal noted that the arguments were similar to those advanced before the motion judge and the Divisional Court.
The Court fixed the respondents' costs on a partial indemnity scale at $45,000, inclusive of disbursements and taxes, payable by the appellants.
Class action certification upheld for franchisees alleging price maintenance and conspiracy by franchisor and distributor.
The appellants, a restaurant franchisor and its food distributor, appealed a Divisional Court decision certifying a class action brought by former franchisees.
The franchisees alleged the appellants engaged in a price maintenance scheme, civil conspiracy, and breach of contract by charging exorbitant prices for supplies.
The Court of Appeal upheld the certification, finding that the motion judge erred by focusing too heavily on the individual nature of damages and failing to recognize that the breach of the Competition Act, conspiracy, and breach of contract claims constituted valid common issues.
The court also affirmed that aggregate damages provisions under the Class Proceedings Act could potentially be utilized at trial.
