Ryan A. Naimark

The applicant sought to introduce fresh evidence on an application for judicial review of a decision by the Director's Delegate, which had upheld an Arbitrator's decision.

The Director's Delegate had previously refused to admit the applicant's affidavit because it failed the Palmer test, as the evidence was available during the arbitration.

The Divisional Court agreed, refusing to admit the affidavit for the purposes of the application.

The court allowed certain other documents to be referenced on consent of the parties, but excluded the accompanying affidavit.

The applicant sought judicial review of an arbitrator's decision, affirmed by the Director's Delegate, awarding costs against him personally in a Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) arbitration.

The Divisional Court applied a reasonableness standard of review.

The court found no denial of procedural fairness, as the applicant had notice and an opportunity to respond.

The court upheld the arbitrator's finding that the applicant caused expenses to be incurred without reasonable cause, and dismissed the application with costs.