The accused, charged with sexual offences against a minor and drug trafficking, brought a Charter application to exclude statements made to police and evidence seized from his home.
The accused had called 911 to report a break and enter, leading police to discover a distraught minor who made allegations against him.
The court found the accused was not initially detained during the preliminary investigation, but his s. 10(b) right to counsel was breached when an officer had him sign a written statement knowing an arrest was imminent.
The court excluded the signed statement under s. 24(2) but admitted the prior oral statements and evidence obtained via search warrants, finding no s. 8 breaches.