Court of Appeal for Ontario

Citation: Lorch v. McHale, 2009 ONCA 161

Date: 2009-02-19

Docket: C49250

Before: Borins, Cronk and LaForme JJ.A.

Between:

Steven Lorch, William Bittner, Stefan Chambers, Craig Cole, Douglas Dinner, Graham Ebert, Peter Fischer, Adoree Fleming, Jamie Gillespie, Guy Higgott, Preven Jepsen, Scott MacPhail, Kyle Miller, Kirkland Richardson, John Rosa, David Smith, Mark Smith, Scott Taylor, Robert Uridil, Michael Whitelaw, Kevin York and Michael Zwarun

Plaintiffs

and

Gary McHale

Defendant

And Between:

Gary McHale

Plaintiff by Counterclaim (Appellant)

and

Steven Lorch, William Bittner, Stefan Chambers, Craig Cole, Douglas Dinner, Graham Ebert, Peter Fischer, Adoree Fleming, Jamie Gillespie, Guy Higgott, Preven Jepsen, Scott MacPhail, Kyle Miller, Kirkland Richardson, John Rosa, David Smith, Mark Smith, Scott Taylor, Robert Uridil, Michael Whitelaw, Kevin York, Michael Zwarun, Karl Walsh, Julian Fantino, Chris Morley, Peter Wilkinson and The County of Haldimand

Defendants by Counterclaim (Respondents)

Counsel:

John Findlay, for the appellant

Odette Soriano, Leslie McIntosh and Edmund Huang, for the respondents

Heard: February 18, 2009

On appeal from the judgment of Justice Sidney N. Lederman of the Superior Court of Justice, dated July 14, 2008.

Appeal Book Endorsement

[1] We agree with the reasons of the motion judge. The appellant’s pleading wholly fails to plead any particulars of the claims alleged.

[2] We would, therefore, dismiss the appeal with costs. Costs to each of the respondents of $6,250, all inclusive.