COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO
RE:
BILL CROFTS, GLENN CAMERON, and LORNE BERGMAN AND THOSE PERSONS LISTED ON SCHEDULE “A” ATTACHED HERETO (Moving Parties/Appellants) –and– TERENCE JULIAN and LOUISE LYELLE JULIAN (Applicants/Respondents in Appeal) –and– THE MUNICIPALITY OF NORTHERN BRUCE PENINSULA, MINISTRY OF NATURAL RESOURCES, DONALD SQUIRE, MARGARET SQUIRE, STEVEN McCUTCHEON, RICHARD McCUTCHEON, RICHARD STEVENS and JOHN KIELLY (Respondents/Respondents in Appeal)
BEFORE:
LABROSSE, LASKIN and GOUDGE JJ.A.
COUNSEL:
Scott M. Merrifield
for the appellants
Frances E. Chapman
for the respondents Terence Julian and Louise Lyelle Julian
HEARD AND ENDORSED:
March 9, 2004
On appeal from the order of Justice S. Bruce Durno of the Superior Court of Justice dated August 2, 2002.
A P P E A L B O O K E N D O R S E M E N T
1The motions judge appears to have proceeded on the basis that some of the existing parties would protect the claims of community use. This assumption appears to be in doubt.
2Accordingly, we would vary paragraph 6 to provide that Bill Crofts be given leave to intervene as an added party pursuant to rule 13.01(1).
3No order as to costs.
SCHEDULE “A”
Don Edgar
William Smith
Wendell Thomson
Bruce E. Hill
R.H. Short
R.J. Hall
Alan MacGillivray
Peter Osborne
Bill Crofts
Phyllis Edgar
Diane Crewe
Kim Ferguson
Gregg Foster
Jim Garland
Eric Repaci
Joe Melleri
Carozza Felice
A. Valentini
Kathy Given
K. Diebel
T. Riaulehn
B. Krerks
Mary Baker
Jean Diebel
Janet Prestipino
Sandra Kent
Clyde Kent
Frank Oliva
Lillian Oliva
John Melfi
Sam Prestipino
Barry Tramble
David Durbin
Monica Durbin
Ricki Durbin
Charlene Hauwert
Lynda Jeffrey
Mark Jeffrey
Ashley Langford
Mackenzie Langford
Jack Sweiger
Doris Sweiger
Tom Sweiger
Janice Sweiger
Kevin Vann
Doug Vann
Fred Van Tooren
Lauren Langford
T.J. Marcella
Gerard Doyle
Marilyn Nigro
Don Nigro
Morris Heit
Robert Heit
Brad Heit
Kathleen Campbell
John Campbell
Karen Sword
Charles MacGillivary
Dale MacGillivray
Thom Marcella
Valerie Marcella
Frank Murray
Mary Murray
Cindy Rozema
Shane Wiseman
John Bain
Marc Parsons
Laura Diebel
Mark Wagner
Ben Oliva
Sam Oliva
Antonia Valente
Kathy Pritchard
Amanda Clarke
Audrey Foster
Ed Heiland
Heather Giavoliello
John Ecsedi
Audrey Foster
Pat Vandenberg
Mrs. J. Hardcastle
Deborah Sheffield
Gary W. James
James Hind
Krysten Black
John Stewart
Tina Christie
Henry Christie
Ron James
Helen Stewart
Bob Stewart
Don Senek
Margaret Trimble
Bruce Trimble
Russ Anderson
Denise Anderson
Amy Eaton
Larry Cooper
Judy Cooper
Wolfgang Possoegel
Joe Marques
Darin Taylor
Sonja Taylor
Paul Joudrey
Jonathan Moore
Jeri-Lee Diebel
Anthony Slirp
Rebecca Peirson
Ellyn Peirson
Doug Peirson
Deanna Morgan
Brian Morgan
Robert Clarke
Mary Weiland
Marley Langford
Tammy Schwartzentruber
D. Miyata
Jossy Johnston
Beverly Weir
Richard Weir
Tabitha Gray
Robyn Tusick
Jill Bewsher
Alyssa Mitchell
Hannah Phillips
Emily Smith
Felker Family
Kareena Felker
Ben Dear
Albert Van Mourik
Jim Belly
Sid Clark
Stella Clark
Lois Wurm
Clarence Wurm
Robert Leach
John Noble
Carrie Salemi
Frank Italiano
Geri Price
Willard Price
Goreta Green
Larry Green
Natalie Randall
Keith Randall
Ryan Nickel
Sean Nickel
Linda Niven
Jamie Niven
Bob MacDonald
Linda MacDonald
Meryl DaCosta
Mike Dobbyn
Dorothy Miyata
Glen Cameron
Wendell Thomson
Lova Bartman
Betty Cameron
Peter Wander
Wanda Myles-Wander
Josephine Hinse
Beverley Davis
Lloyd Davis
Brian Boyd
Annie Baccin
Donna Tifton
Serina Hurd
Jane Merrifield
Amy Ward
Gillian Merrifield
Meg Smith
Bailey Smith
Irene Corman
Tom Corman
Tianna Marcella
Dylan Eliored
Pat Melleri
Mary Ann McCutcheon
Steven McCutcheon
Connie Pearson
Art Pearson
Jennifer Eaton
Steve Eaton
Jeff Eaton
Amy Eaton
Jim Rivedale
Fay Wiseman
Ben Diebel
Simon Davies
Corinne Davies
Kristin Vilcins
Jonathan Weiland
Tracy DeVille
Derek Deville
Ruth Tomlin
Larry Tomlin
Jerry Hobb
Karen Davies
Bob Draycott
Kath Italiano
Rade Miskovic
Helena Miskovic
Goran Miskovic
Mili Miskovic
Brivela Miskovic
Newton Thomas Jr.
Adriana Thomas
Newton Thomas Sr.
Rick Nigro
Scott Noble
Giovanni Baccin
Rose VanDoninck
Joe VanDoninck
Lisa Dwyer
John Dwyer
Sean Dwyer
John Coleman
Walter Rota
Francine Scremin
Joanne Davis
Henry Hess
Jan Hember
Jamie Hember
Joy Taber
Jim Taber
Jon Dobbyn
Marilyn Dobbyn
Brianne Nigro
Trevor Wey
Leszek Plauszta
Hudpen Kotouski
Suzan Pokluda
Kris Hilts
John Schaefer
Kathy Schaefer
Matt Schedler
Vanessa Somos
Melissa Lee
Emma-Lee DeVille
Danielle DeVille
Pat Ingram
Ben Ingram
Marion Draycott
K.M. Tozser
Janet Noble
S. Tadic
Dave Green
Maggie Green
Dan Varda
Fran Liverance
Adam Nigro
Ed Pritchard
Michelle MacGregor
Tom Hewitt
Brenda Hewitt
Freda Hewitt
Janice Lindman
E. Ecsedi
Joanne Butler
Henry Butler
Rhonda Karn
Charity Eb
Barbara Langford
D. Hardcastle
Jamie Hewitt
Jason Whitlock
Jim Marcella
Chris Marcella
Jean Van Tonen
H. Schooley
Ryan Lawrenson
Carrie Wolfe
Karissa Henshaw
Lindsay Copp
Michelle Swadzba
Cathy Parsons
Theresa Swadzba
Graham Lawrenson
Tim Duff
Wilda Duff
Matt Lawrenson
Lindsay Kelly
Colleen Crowe
Jamie Crowe
Lena Yost
Teresa Marchand
Dave Grundy
James Garland
Robert Parsons
Jane Lawrenson
Shawn Cherrington
Paul Duff
Brian Fecker
Don Collins
Pete Heyblom
Brenda Heyblom
Paul Smith
Carol Smith
Mark Ruffey
Betty Boyes
Jim Boyes
Greg Rich
Justin Cormier
Pat Bergman
Lorne Bergman
Marita Hendriks
Sue Bellmore
Doug Bellmore
Tom Cowley
Ryan Haviland
Ann Hodgins
Shaun Schedler
Sue Finley
John Finley
Walter Hendricks
Cathy DuRoche
Mary Grundy