Norm Emblem

The plaintiffs sued the defendant lawyer and accountant for professional negligence, alleging they failed to protect the plaintiffs' ownership interest in a corporation.

The defendants brought third-party claims against the corporation and its principals.

The defendants and third parties moved for summary judgment to stay the action, relying on a general release previously signed by the plaintiffs in a settlement with the corporation.

The court granted the motions, finding that although the defendants were not parties to the release, allowing the action to proceed would trigger third-party claims against the released parties, violating the no-claims-over provision.

The main action and third-party proceedings were permanently stayed as an abuse of process.

Following the dismissal of an application to enforce Letters of Request from a US court, the court determined the costs payable by the applicants.

Pursuant to a prior consent order, the applicants were ordered to pay $260,888.72 for the respondents' reasonable direct costs of collecting and producing documents, which included third-party vendor fees and legal review time.

The court also awarded the respondents $75,000 in partial indemnity costs for successfully defending the application, finding the amount reasonable and proportional given the importance and stakes of the cross-border litigation.