The court fixed the successful plaintiffs' costs at $25,000, denying substantial indemnity costs because the defendants' opposition was not reprehensible.
This endorsement addresses the costs of a successful motion by the plaintiffs to add new defendants and amend their Statement of Claim.
The plaintiffs sought substantial indemnity costs, arguing the motion was unnecessarily complicated by the responding parties.
The court found the plaintiffs were entitled to costs but not on a substantial indemnity basis, as there was no reprehensible conduct by the opposing parties.
The court fixed the plaintiffs' costs at $25,000, inclusive of disbursements and HST, payable jointly and severally by the responding parties within 30 days, rejecting the suggestion to reserve costs to the trial judge.
Motion to add parties and amend pleadings granted where plaintiffs alleged corporate restructuring to defeat claims.
The plaintiffs brought a motion to add a new corporate defendant and several individual defendants, and to amend their Statement of Claim to increase damages to $8,000,000 and assert claims of fraud.
The plaintiffs alleged that the original defendant transferred its business and assets to the new corporate defendant to defeat the plaintiffs' claims regarding environmental contamination advice.
The court granted the motion, finding that the plaintiffs moved with sufficient dispatch upon discovering the new corporation and that the allegations were more conveniently dealt with in the present action.
