R. Wright

The accused was charged with manslaughter as a party to a stabbing death that occurred during a parking lot altercation.

The Crown argued the accused was liable under s. 21(1)(a) or s. 21(2) of the Criminal Code because he participated in a group assault during which another individual stabbed the victim.

The court found that the victim's group instigated the confrontation and that the stabber's use of a knife was an unforeseeable intervening act.

The accused was found not guilty.

The offenders were sentenced following a jury trial where Bengy was convicted of second degree murder and Modeste was convicted of manslaughter in relation to the stabbing death of Brandon Ramdeen.

Bengy, who stabbed the unarmed victim while he was overpowered, was sentenced to life imprisonment with no parole eligibility for 11 years.

Modeste, who participated in the group assault but did not stab the victim, was sentenced to 5 years imprisonment, with 49.5 months remaining after credit for pre-trial custody.