The appellant moving company appealed a Small Claims Court judgment awarding the respondent $22,419.00 in damages for retaining her personal property.
The dispute arose when the appellant demanded $889.88 instead of the agreed $500.00 for a move, and subsequently placed the respondent's property in storage when she refused to pay the higher amount.
The Superior Court of Justice dismissed the appeal, finding no overriding and palpable error in the trial judge's conclusions that there was a fixed price contract and that the damage award was appropriate.
The court also rejected the appellant's claim of judicial bias.