Heritage designation upheld based on contextual value despite failing design and historical criteria.
The appellant owner appealed the City of Ottawa's by-law designating their property under the Ontario Heritage Act.
The owner intended to demolish the existing c. 1912 house to build two new homes.
The Tribunal evaluated the property against three criteria under O. Reg. 9/06.
While finding insufficient evidence to establish design/physical value or historical/associative value, the Tribunal concluded the property has contextual value as it helps define, support, and maintain the character of the Highland Park area.
The appeal was allowed in part, but the designation was upheld based on contextual value.
OLTOntario Land TribunalFeb 20, 2024
