The appellant appealed the Niagara Escarpment Commission's conditional approval of a development permit application to demolish existing structures and construct a large single dwelling on a property designated as Escarpment Protection Area.

The appellant argued the proposed development's size and visual impact would negatively affect the open landscape character and scenic resources of the area.

The Hearing Officer accepted the expert evidence of the applicant and the Commission that the proposed development is a permitted use and accords with the relevant objectives and development criteria of the Niagara Escarpment Plan.

The appeal was dismissed and the Commission's decision was confirmed.

The appellant appealed the Niagara Escarpment Commission's conditional approval of a development permit recognizing the demolition of a barn on an adjacent property.

The appellant argued that additional conditions were required, including an archaeological assessment, a full site plan, and soil testing for contaminants that might affect his organic farm.

The Hearing Officers found that a full site plan and soil testing were unnecessary.

However, given the historical nature of the site and the likelihood of soil disturbance during demolition, the Hearing Officers recommended adding a condition requiring Phase 1 and 2 archaeological assessments.

The Minister subsequently confirmed the NEC's decision to issue the permit subject to the conditions.