Evan Manning

The City of Markham passed a by-law designating a property containing a one-storey brick dwelling as a heritage property under the Ontario Heritage Act.

The property owner appealed the designation to the Ontario Land Tribunal.

The Tribunal evaluated the property against the prescribed criteria and found that while it met the criterion for design or physical value as a modest Ontario Cottage style tradesman's dwelling, it did not meet the criteria for historical or contextual value.

Because a property must meet a minimum of two criteria to be eligible for designation, the Tribunal allowed the appeal and ordered the by-law repealed.

The City of Markham passed a by-law designating a 1890s farmhouse as a property of cultural heritage value under the Ontario Heritage Act.

The applicant appealed the designation, arguing that the property only met one of the required criteria.

The Tribunal found that while the property met the criterion for design value as a representative Gothic Revival farmhouse, it did not meet the criteria for historical or contextual value.

As a property must meet at least two criteria to be eligible for designation, the Tribunal allowed the appeal and ordered the by-law repealed.