This motion addressed refusals arising from examinations for discovery in a personal injury action.
The plaintiff was involved in two motor vehicle accidents, and the defendants sought disclosure on several matters, including a novel issue regarding Costs Liability Insurance.
The court directed the plaintiff to provide information concerning a prior assault incident and, crucially, to disclose the existence of any adverse costs indemnity or insurance coverage, deeming it relevant under Rule 30.02(3) of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the resolution of personal injury disputes.