The applicant sought permission under section 45 of the Planning Act to change the legal non-conforming use of the property from an automobile service station to a retail, leasing, and repair facility for light construction equipment.
The City and area residents opposed the application, arguing that the previous use had been abandoned and that the new use caused significant adverse impacts, including noise, odours, and traffic issues.
The Committee of Adjustment refused the application, finding insufficient evidence that the legal non-conforming use had continued until the date of the application.
Furthermore, the Committee concluded that the proposed use was not desirable, created unacceptable adverse impacts on the neighbourhood, and was less compatible than the former use.