CITATION: 1186708 Ontario Inc. v. Gerstein, 2021 ONSC 2909
DIVISIONAL COURT FILE NO.: 073/21
COURT FILE NO.: CV-14-10668-00CL
DATE: 20210423
ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
DIVISIONAL COURT
Aston, Backhouse and Favreau, JJ.
BETWEEN:
11867009 1186708 ONTARIO INC.,
746190 ONTARIO LIMITED and 746191 ONTARIO LIMITED
Plaintiffs/Respondents
– and –
ELLIOTT J. GERSTEIN, IRIS L. GERSTEIN, THE ESTATE OF SYDNEY GERSTEIN, ATTARA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, BELLCREST BUILDERS LIMITED, BRENTHALL APARTMENTS LIMITED, CHELSANDY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, GROVER
REALTY MANAGEMENT (a partnership), GROVER REALTY CABLE (a
partnership), LILLIANA BUILDING LIMITED, LURAY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, PAULDOR DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 375685 ONTARIO LIMITED, STAN VINE CONSTRUCTION LTD, KILBARRY HOLDING CORPORATION, 678678 ONTARIO LIMITED, MATANAH INVESTMENTS CORP., DAWN TRADING LTD., 497505 ONTARIO INC., 781527 ONTARIO INC., 781526 ONTARIO INC., ANDREA MINTZ AND RICHARD MINTZ ESTATE TRUSTEES OF SAUL MINTZ, IRWIN MINTZ, HOWARD MINTZ, THE ESTATE OF FAYE MINTZ, MINTZ & PARTNERS (a
partnership), RHONDA STRASBERG,
P. James Zibarras, for the Plaintiffs/Respondents
Linda Galessiere, Douglas B. Stewart, Deepshikha Dutt, Gilda Niman and James P. McReynolds, for the Defendants/Moving Parties
Page: 2
ESTATE OF BELLE MERNICK,
MINKIDS HOLDINGS (a partnership),
ETTIE WOSNICK, MORRIS WOSNICK,
2135637 ONTARIO INC., LERRIC
INVESTMENTS CORP., MERNICK
CONSTRUCTION LIMITED and
STANMORE DEVELOPMENTS
LIMITED
Defendants/Respondents
HEARD IN WRITING: April 23, 2021
Decision on Motion For Leave to Appeal
[1] The motion for leave to appeal the Order of Justice Koehnen made on January 11, 2021 is dismissed. As agreed by the parties, the Plaintiffs/Moving Parties shall pay costs to the Defendants/Respondents as follows: $10,000 to the Mintz Family Group and
$7,500 to SRTS LLP.
Aston, J.
Backhouse, J.
Favreau, J.
Released: April 23, 2021
CITATION: 1186708 Ontario Inc. v. Gerstein, 2021 ONSC 2909
DIVISIONAL COURT FILE NO.: 073/21
COURT FILE NO.: CV-14-10668-00CL
DATE: 20210423
11867009 1186708 ONTARIO INC., 746190 ONTARIO LIMITED and 746191 ONTARIO LIMITED
Plaintiffs/Respondents
– and –
ELLIOTT J. GERSTEIN, IRIS L. GERSTEIN, THE ESTATE OF SYDNEY GERSTEIN, ATTARA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, BELLCREST BUILDERS LIMITED, BRENTHALL APARTMENTS LIMITED, CHELSANDY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, GROVER REALTY MANAGEMENT (a
partnership), GROVER REALTY CABLE (a partnership), LILLIANA BUILDING LIMITED, LURAY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, PAULDOR DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 375685 ONTARIO LIMITED, STAN VINE CONSTRUCTION LTD, KILBARRY HOLDING CORPORATION, 678678 ONTARIO LIMITED, MATANAH INVESTMENTS CORP., DAWN TRADING LTD., 497505 ONTARIO INC., 781527 ONTARIO INC., 781526 ONTARIO INC., ANDREA MINTZ AND RICHARD MINTZ ESTATE TRUSTEES OF SAUL MINTZ, IRWIN MINTZ, HOWARD MINTZ, THE ESTATE OF FAYE
MINTZ, MINTZ & PARTNERS (a partnership), RHONDA STRASBERG, ESTATE OF BELLE
MERNICK, MINKIDS HOLDINGS (a partnership), ETTIE WOSNICK, MORRIS WOSNICK, 2135637 ONTARIO INC., LERRIC INVESTMENTS CORP., MERNICK CONSTRUCTION LIMITED and STANMORE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED
Defendants/Moving Paties
DECISION ON MOTION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
Released: April 23, 2021