Ontario Land Tribunal
Tribunal ontarien de l’aménagement du territoire
ISSUE DATE:
June 25, 2021
CASE NO(S).:
PL171084
PL180158
PL180580
MM170004
MM180022
The Ontario Municipal Board (the “OMB”) and the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal (the “LPAT”) is continued under the name Ontario Land Tribunal (the “Tribunal”), and any reference to the Ontario Municipal Board or Board or Local Planning Appeal Tribunal in any publication of the Tribunal is deemed to be a reference to the Tribunal.
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 22(7) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Applicant and Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Inc.
Subject:
Request to amend the Official Plan - Refusal of request by the Town of Oakville
Existing Designation:
Private Open Space and Natural Area
Proposed Designated:
Site Specific (to be determined)- including Residential, Mixed Use and Community Commercial
Purpose:
To permit the redevelopment of the Subject Lands for a mix of residential, commercial and open space uses
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Approval Authority File No.:
OPA.1519.09
OMB Case No.:
PL171084
OMB File No.:
PL171084
OMB Case Name:
Clublink Corporation ULC v. Oakville (Town)
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 34(11) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Applicant and Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Inc.
Subject:
Application to amend Zoning By-law No. 2014-014 - Refusal of Application by the Town of Oakville
Existing Zoning:
Private Open Space (O2), Private Open Space- Special (O2- Sp.114), and Natural Area (N)
Proposed Zoning:
Site Specific (to be determined)
Purpose:
To permit the redevelopment of the Subject Lands for a mix of residential, commercial and open space uses
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Municipality File No.:
Z.1519.09
OMB Case No.:
PL171084
OMB File No.:
PL171085
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 51(34) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Applicant and Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Plan of Subdivision - Failure of the Town of Oakville to make a decision
Purpose:
To permit the redevelopment of the Subject Lands for a mix of residential, commercial and open space uses
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Municipality File No.:
24T-17003/1519
OMB Case No.:
PL171084
OMB File No.:
PL171086
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 51(34) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Applicant and Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Plan of Subdivision - Failure of the Town of Oakville to make a decision
Purpose:
To permit the redevelopment of the Subject Lands for a mix of residential, commercial and open space uses
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Municipality File No.:
24T-17003/1519
OMB Case No.:
PL171084
OMB File No.:
PL171167
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 51(39) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Plan of Subdivision
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Municipality File No.:
24T-17003/1519
OMB Case No.:
PL171084
OMB File No.:
PL180034
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 17(24) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Official Plan Amendment No. 24
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Tribunal Case No.:
PL180158
Tribunal File No.:
PL180158
Tribunal Case Name:
ClubLink Corporation ULC et al. v. Oakville (Town)
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 34(19) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
By-law No. 2018-016
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
Tribunal Case No.:
PL180158
Tribunal File No.:
PL180159
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 17(36) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Official Plan Amendment No. OPA 15
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
LPAT Case No.:
PL180580
LPAT File No.:
PL180580
LPAT Case Name:
Clublink Corporation ULC v. Oakville (Town)
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 17(36) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
Clublink Corporation ULC and Clublink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Proposed Official Plan Amendment No. OPA 16
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
LPAT Case No.:
PL180580
LPAT File No.:
PL180581
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 69(3) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended
Appellant:
ClubLink Corporation ULC & ClubLink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Protest the levying of fees in relation to an application for approval of a draft plan of subdivision, Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment
Property Address/Description:
1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
LPAT Case No.:
MM170004
LPAT File No.:
MM170004
LPAT Case Name:
ClubLink Corporation ULC v. Oakville (Town)
PROCEEDING COMMENCED UNDER subsection 34.1(1) of the Ontario Heritage Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.18, as amended
Appellant:
ClubLink Corporation ULC & ClubLink Holdings Ltd.
Subject:
Appeal of the Decision of Council on an application to demolish or remove a building or structure
Property Address/Description:
1313 and 1333 Dorval Drive
Municipality:
Town of Oakville
LPAT Case No.:
MM180022
LPAT File No.:
MM180022
LPAT Case Name:
Clublink Corporation ULC et al v. Oakville (Town)
Heard:
June 4 and 22, 2021 by telephone conference call
APPEARANCES:
Parties
Counsel
Town of Oakville (“Town”)
Robert Howe
Catherine Lyons
Nadia Chandra
Jessica Jakubowski (Student-at-law)
ClubLink Corporation ULC and
Mark Flowers
ClubLink Holdings Ltd. (“ClubLink”)
Kyle Gossen
Regional Municipality of Halton
Isaac Tang
(“Halton Region”)
Katie Butler
Halton Region Conservation Authority
Konstantine Stavrakos
(“HRCA”)
Fairway Hills Community Association
Denise Baker
(“Fairway Hills”)
MEMORANDUM OF ORAL DECISION DELIVERED BY DAVID L. LANTHIER ON JUNE 4 and JUNE 22, 2021 AND ORDER OF THE TRIBUNAL
1The Case Management Conference (“CMC”) addressed in this Decision and Order is expected to be the final case management hearing event preceding the commencement of the hearing of these Appeals on August 9, 2021.
2The CMC for June 22, 2021 was scheduled following the CMC held on May 11, 2021, and the Decision and Order issued on May 26, 2021, with the expectation that the Tribunal would receive the final draft of the calendar-projected work plan and attend to the few remaining matters.
3However, prior to this date, the parties jointly requested an interim telephone conference call to address further scheduling matters necessary to permit the completion of that draft work plan. This Decision and Order now addresses the additional directions and orders provided on June 4 and June 22, 2021.
ADDITIONAL HEARING TIME – TECHNICAL DISCIPLINE EVIDENCE
4The parties, through ongoing discussions, tentatively proposed to hive off the technical discipline evidence and issues in the specific areas of geomorphology, geotechnology, hydrology, hydrogeology, stormwater management, aquatic biology and natural heritage, and deal with them separately within an additional five-week hearing period to be scheduled in 2022. This division of the evidence would then allow the parties to devise a workplan that would permit a four-day hearing week, taking into account the two weeks that the Tribunal would stand down from August 16 to August 27, 2021. The parties accordingly requested an additional opportunity to speak to this Panel Member on June 4, 2021, at which time the proposed segmenting of the evidence and issues into these two blocks of hearing time was endorsed by the Tribunal.
5Following the conclusion of the first block of hearing time from August 9 to December 23, 2021, and the closing submissions scheduled for January 12, 13 and 14, 2022, the Tribunal has now set aside five weeks of hearing time commencing June 1, 2022, tentatively to continue as a virtual hearing.
6The connection coordinates for this additional five-week period will be provided at a later date. Based on the information from the parties, it is possible that they may eventually be able to resolve all or some of the technical evidence issues such that all or part of the additional five weeks of hearing time may be released from the Tribunal’s calendar.
7The parties will, by mutual arrangement, re-set dates for the exchange of witness statements for the technical discipline evidence from what was previously agreed-upon and provided for in paragraphs 14 and 16 of the Procedural Order, and paragraphs 22 and 23 of the Decision and Order of May 26, 2021. This will be addressed with the Hearing Panel in the course of the hearing.
HEARING PLAN
8The draft hearing work plan directed in paragraph 18 and 19 of the prior Decision and Order, is now based upon a four-day per week format for the period from August 9, 2021 to December 17, 2021 and has been provided and reviewed by the Tribunal. Subject to such further directions as the Hearing Panel may provide, the hearing of these Appeals will now be governed by the Draft Hearing Plan attached to this Decision as Attachment 1.
9The Hearing Panel will additionally be available to sit on Friday, August 13, 2021, if determined to be necessary, and all counsel and witnesses should ensure that they remain available for this possibility.
OTHER DIRECTIONS
10The following additional directions were provided by the Tribunal, all of them subject to the overriding discretion of the presiding Hearing Panel:
(a) Those individual days already removed from the scheduled hearing time pursuant to the prior directives of the Tribunal will determine the remaining four days that the Panel will sit in those weeks. Otherwise, the expectation is that the Tribunal and the hearing will stand-down on the Friday of each week;
(b) It is tentatively expected that a three-member Panel will preside over these Appeals.
(c) Hard copies of the Joint Document Book(s) and the compendium of witness statements, Curriculum Vitae(s) and Acknowledgements of Expert’s Duty are not required by the Tribunal. Instead, the parties will cooperate to provide one USB key for each of the three Panel Members containing the Joint Document Book and one additional USB key for each Member containing the compendium of witness statement materials. In addition, the Case Coordinator will be provided with one additional USB key of each of the two document collections.
(d) All PDF documents are to be tabulated and paginated with bookmarks and tables of content. Any site plans, surveys, sketches, or other technical documents, particularly those containing fine print, are to be provided is scaleable PDF format for easy enlargement.
(e) The USB keys are to be delivered to the Tribunal not later than July 21, 2021 in order to permit distribution to the Panel Members.
(f) The Tribunal has been advised that opening submissions will be delivered on the first day of the hearing by ClubLink, the Town and the Region. HRCA and Fairway Hills will likely reserve their opening submissions to the start of their case.
(g) The parties have advised the Tribunal that they wish to use the services of a Verbatim Reporter for the purposes of providing an ongoing written transcript of the proceedings with the intention of distributing transcripts of each week’s proceedings on a weekly basis. This request is approved. Counsel for the Town, or a representative of the Verbatim Reporter is to contact the Tribunal’s Case Coordinator, Jason Kwan for the purposes of coordinating such recording services for the electronic hearing.
(h) In accordance with Rule 22.9 of the Tribunal’s Rules of Practice and Procedure (“Rules”) the Case Coordinator, on behalf of the Panel Members, will be provided with an electronic copy of the transcript, as provided by the Verbatim Reporter each week. The delivery of the transcripts to the Tribunal shall be concurrent with the delivery of the transcript to the parties and provided free of charge.
(i) Arrangements for the hearing of any Reply evidence by ClubLink, which is not currently provided for in the Draft Hearing Plan, will be determined by the Hearing Panel.
EXPERT WITNESS OBSERVERS
11For clarification, and in order to ensure that there is direct and uninterrupted observation of the evidence, all expert witnesses observing the hearing for the purposes of their respective retainers, may access the electronic hearing by logging directly into the GoToMeeting platform in accordance with paragraphs 10 to 12 of the Decision and Order of the Tribunal issued on May 26, 2021.
12All expert witnesses who are observing, and not testifying, are directed to turn off their cameras and mute their microphones before logging into the hearing each day.
13All other members of the public wishing to observe the conduct of the Hearing will access via the YouTube live-streaming as set out in paragraph 9 of that same Decision and Order.
RECORDING OF HEARING PROHIBITED
14Due to the extent of the public and media interest in these proceedings thus far, the Tribunal hereby confirms and orders that unless authorized by the Tribunal or the Hearing Panel pursuant to Rule 22.5 to 22.7 of the Tribunal’s Rules, the taking of, or attempting to take, a screenshot, photograph, motion picture, video or any other recording of any portion of the hearing of these Appeals, or the dissemination of any still shot or recording of any portion of these proceedings at any time, is strictly prohibited.
15Under s. 29 of the Statutory Powers Procedure Act, contravening this prohibition against recording constitutes an offence, subject to a fine of up to $25,000 on conviction.
OTHER MATTERS
16The Tribunal so orders and provides these CMC directives for the purposes of the case management of these Appeals.
17All directions and orders here, and previously, provided for the purposes of the case management of these Appeals are subject to the discretion of the Panel Members presiding over the hearing.
“David L. Lanthier”
DAVID L. LANTHIER
VICE-CHAIR
Ontario Land Tribunal
Website: www.olt.gov.on.ca Telephone: 416-212-6349 Toll Free: 1-866-448-2248
The Conservation Review Board, the Environmental Review Tribunal, the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal and the Mining and Lands Tribunal are amalgamated and continued as the Ontario Land Tribunal.
PL171084 et al. – Attachment 1
Glen Abbey Hearing Plan
Estimated Time for Examination in Chief = X Estimated Time for Cross Examination = X
Week 1
August 9-13
Morning
Afternoon
9
Opening Submissions
All Parties
(0.5 day)
10
Fact Witness
Andrew Keffer
Executive Director of Turf Operations for ClubLink
(0.5 day in chief)
11
Golf course architecture and design
Thomas McBroom
Thomas McBroom Associates Ltd.
(1 day in chief)
12
Golf course architecture and design
Thomas McBroom
Thomas McBroom Associates Ltd.
(0.5 day in cross)
13
9
Non-Opinion Overview
David Capper
Glen Schnarr & Associates
(0.5 day)
10
Fact Witness
Andrew Keffer
Executive Director of Turf Operations for ClubLink
(2 hrs in cross)
11
Golf course architecture and design
Thomas McBroom
Thomas McBroom Associates Ltd.
(1 day in chief)
12
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland ERA
(2.5 days in chief)
Week 2
August 30-September 2
Morning
Afternoon
30
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2.5 days in chief)
31
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2.5 days in chief)
1
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes and heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2 days + 0.5 hr + 1 hr in cross)
2
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2 days + 0.5 hr + 1 hr in cross)
3
30
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
RA
(2.5 days in chief)
31
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes & heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2.5 days in chief)
1
Heritage planning, cultural heritage landscapes and heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2 days + 0.5 hr + 1 hr in cross)
2
Heritage planning,cultural heritage landscapes and heritage architecture
Michael McClelland
ERA
(2 days + 0.5 hr + 1 hr in cross)
Week 3
September 7-10
Morning
Afternoon
6
LABOUR DAY
7
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(2 days in chief)
8
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(2 days in chief)
9
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(1.5 days + 1 hr in cross)
10
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(1.5 days + 1 hr in cross)
7
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(2 days in chief)
8
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(2 days in chief)
9
Heritage Planning, cultural heritage landscapes and landscape architecture
Brendan Stewart
University of Guelph/ Consultant ERA
(1.5 days + 1 hr in cross)
10
Servicing
Steve Schaefer
SCS Consulting Group Ltd.
(1 day in chief)
Week 4
September 13-17
Morning
Afternoon
13
14
Servicing
Steve Schaefer
SCS Consulting Group Ltd.
(1 day in chief)
15
Urban Design
Ute Maya Giambattista
Fotenn Consultants Inc.
(1 day in chief)
16
Urban Design
Ute Maya Giambattista
Fotenn Consultants Inc.
(0.5 day + 0.5 hr + 1hr in cross)
17
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.5 in chief)
14
Servicing
Steve Schaefer
SCS Consulting Group Ltd.
(0.5 days in cross)
15
Urban Design
Ute Maya Giambattista
Fotenn Consultants Inc.
(1 day in chief)
16
Urban Design
Ute Maya Giambattista
Fotenn Consultants Inc.
(0.5 day + 0.5 hr + 1hr in cross)
17
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.5 in chief)
Week 5
September 20-24
Morning
Afternoon
20
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.5 in chief)
21
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.5 in chief)
22
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
23
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
24
20
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.5 in chief)
21
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
22
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
23
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
Week 6
September 27-October 1
Morning
Afternoon
27
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
28
Land economics and market analysis
Robyn Brown
IBI Group Inc.
(0.5 day in chief)
29
Fire Services
Rick Monkman OR*
Phil Dawson
Emergency Management & Training Inc.
(0.5 day in chief)
30
Land economics and
municipal finance
Audrey Jacob
IBI Group Inc.
(0.5 day in chief)
1
27
Transportation planning and traffic engineering
Mark Jamieson
BA Consulting Group Ltd.
(2.75 + 0.75 day in cross)
28
Land economics and market analysis
Robyn Brown
IBI Group Inc.
(0.5 day + 0.5 hr in cross)
29
Fire Services
Rick Monkman OR*
Phil Dawson
Emergency Management & Training Inc.
(0.5 day in cross)
30
Land economics and
municipal finance
Audrey Jacob
IBI Group Inc.
(0.5 day + 0.5 hr in cross)
Week 7
October 4-8
Morning
Afternoon
4
5
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days in chief)
6
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days in chief)
7
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
8
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
5
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days in chief)
6
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days in chief)
7
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
8
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
Week 8
October 11-15
Morning
Afternoon
11
12
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
13
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2.5 days in chief)
14
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2.5 days in chief)
15
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2.5 days in chief)
12
Land use planning
Peter Smith
Bousfields Inc.
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
13
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2.5 days in chief)
14
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2.5 days in chief)
15
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
Week 9
October 18-22
Morning
Afternoon
18
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
19
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
20
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
21
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(2 days in chief)
22
18
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
19
Land use planning
David Capper
Glenn Schnarr & Associates
(2 days + 0.75 day + 1 hr in cross)
20
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(2 days in chief)
21
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(2 days in chief)
Week 10
October 25-29
Morning
Afternoon
25
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(2 days in chief)
26
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(1.5 day in cross)
27
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(2 days in chief)
28
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(2 days in chief)
29
25
Cultural Heritage
Julian Smith
Julian Smith & Associates Architects
(1.5 day in cross)
26
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(1.5 days in cross)
27
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(2 days in chief)
28
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(2 days in chief)
Week 11
November 1-5
Morning
Afternoon
1
2
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(1.5 days in cross)
3
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(1.5 days in cross)
4
Heritage Planner
Susan Schappert
Town of Oakville
(1 day in cross)
5
Land Use Planner
Lesley Gill Woods
Town of Oakville
(1 day in chief)
2
Golf Course Architect/Historic Golf Courses
Ken Moodie
Creative Golf Design
(1.5 days in cross)
3
Heritage Planner
Susan Schappert
Town of Oakville
(0.5 day in chief)
4
Heritage Planner
Susan Schappert
Town of Oakville
(1 day in cross)
5
Land Use Planner
Lesley Gill Woods
Town of Oakville
(1 day in chief)
Week 12
November 8-12
Morning
Afternoon
8
Land Use Planner
Lesley Gill Wood
Town of Oakville
(1 day in cross)
9
Community Facilities Services Planner
Steve Langlois
Monteith Brown Planning Consultants
(0.5 day in chief)
10
Fire Services
Andy Glynn
Town of Oakville
(0.5 day in chief)
11
12
Planning/Environmental Planning
(fee appeal)
Jessica Bester Conservation Authority
(0.5 day in chief)
8
Land Use Planner
Lesley Gill Woods
Town of Oakville
(1 day in cross)
9
Community Facilities Services Planner
Steve Langlois
Monteith Brown Planning Consultants
(0.25 day in cross)
10
Fire Services
Andy Glynn
Town of Oakville
(0.25 day in cross)
12
Planning/Environmental Planning
(fee appeal)
Jessica Bester
Conservation Authority
(0.25 day in cross)
Week 13
November 15-19
Morning
Afternoon
15
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in chief)
16
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in chief)
17
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in cross)
18
Infrastructure Engineer
Chris Hamel
GM Bluepan
(0.5 day in chief)
19
15
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in chief)
16
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in cross)
17
Land Use Planner
Curt Benson
Halton Region
(1.5 day in cross)
18
Infrastructure Engineer
Chris Hamel
GM Bluepan
(0.5 day in cross)
Week 14
November 22-26
Morning
Afternoon
22
Servicing Engineer
Zahir Najak
Halton Region
(0.25 day in chief)
(0.25 day in cross)
23
Transportation and Traffic Engineering
Saroush Salek
CIMA+
(0.5 day in cross)
24
Transportation Planning
Matt Krusto*
Jaime Garcia
Halton Region
(0.75 day in cross)
25
Transportation Engineer
Mira Vervoon
Hatch
(2 days in chief)
26
22
Transportation and Traffic Engineering
Saroush Salek
CIMA+
(0.75 day in chief)
23
Transportation Planning
Matt Krusto
Halton Region
*Panelled with
Jaime Garcia
CIMA+
(0.75 day panel)
24
Transportation Engineer
Mira Vervoon
Hatch
(2 days in chief)
25
Transportation Engineer
Mira Vervoon
Hatch
(2 days in chief)
Week 15
November 29-December3
Morning
Afternoon
29
Transportation Engineer—Mira Vervoon, Hatch
(2 days in chief)
30
Transportation Engineer—Mira Vervoon, Hatch
(1.25 days in cross)
1
Land Use Planner—Nick McDonald, Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in chief)
2
Land Use Planner—Nick McDonald, Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in chief)
3
29
Transportation Engineer
Mira Vervoon
Hatch
(1.25 days in cross)
30
Transportation Engineer
Mira Vervoon
Hatch
(1.25 days in cross)
1
Land Use Planner
Nick McDonald Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in chief)
2
Land Use Planner
Nick McDonald Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in cross)
Week 16
December 6-10
Morning
Afternoon
6
Land Use Planner
Nick McDonald
Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in cross)
7
Land economics/housing market (reply to P. Smith)
Jaime Cook
Watson & Associates
(0.5 day in chief)
8
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
9
10
6
Land Use Planner
Nick McDonald
Meridian Planning
(1.5 days in cross)
7
Land economics/ housing market (reply to P. Smith)
Jamie Cook
Watson & Associates
(0.5 day in cross)
8
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
Week 17
December 13-17
Morning
Afternoon
13
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
14
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
15
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
16
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
17
13
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
14
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
15
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(4.5 days in chief)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
16
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
Week 18
December
20-24
Morning
Afternoon
20
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
21
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled w/ Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
22
Land Use Planner Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
23
Lay witness
Jennifer Capitelli
FHRA
(0.25 day in cross)
24
20
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled with
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
21
Land Use Planner
Elizabeth Howson
MSH
(3 days in cross)
*Panelled w/
Paul Barrette, Town of Oakville
22
Lay witness
Jennifer Capitelli
FHRA
(0.5 day in chief)
September 6 and 13; October 4 and 11; November 1 and 11; and December 9 and 10—TRIBUNAL NOT SITTING