GSB# 2019-0144
UNION# 2019-0248-0010
Full list of files attached in “Appendix A”
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Adamiec et al)
Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of the Solicitor General)
Employer
BEFORE
Brian P. Sheehan
Arbitrator
FOR THE UNION
Gregg Gray
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
Grievance Officer
FOR THE EMPLOYER
James Cheng
Treasury Board Secretariat
Employee Relations Advisor
HEARING
August 26, 2020 (by videoconference)
DECISION
1In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was agreed that overtime grievances would be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely manner to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each institution. Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped that these monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances.
2It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to deal exclusively with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would meet to attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining disputes would be put before this Board.
3In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. Since that time a number of sessions have been held and various decisions rendered. The process has not been altered and continues to serve the parties well.
4The grievances determined herein were dealt with on August 26, 2020.
5Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and made submissions regarding the various disputes. Attached as Appendix A is the list of grievances and the disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors as set out in the attached appendix are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate less statutory deductions.
6I remain seized.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 3rd day of November, 2020.
Appendix A
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
Adamiec, Rafal
2019-0248-0010
2019-0144
03/06/2019
Upheld - 12 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Bin Othman, Ahmed
2019-0248-0011
2019-0145
03/06/2019
Upheld - 4 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Schroeder, Ryan
2019-0248-0012
2019-0146
03/07/2019
Upheld - 4 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Warne, Edward
2019-0248-0013
2019-0147
03/06/2019
Dismissed
Coudenys, Michael
2019-0248-0014
2019-0148
03/06/2019
Upheld - 4 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Doner, Clayton
2019-0248-0015
2019-0149
03/06/2019
Upheld - 4 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Anttila, Kari et al
2019-0248-0004
2019-0138
03/07/2019
Dismissed
Scriven, Robert
2019-0248-0005
2019-0139
03/06/2019
Upheld - 12 hours OT
Malcolmson, Gregg
2019-0248-0006
2019-0140
03/06/2019
Upheld - 12 hours OT
Champagne, Nicole
2019-0248-0007
2019-0141
03/06/2019
Upheld - 12 hours OT
Devries, Melissa
2019-0248-0008
2019-0142
03/07/2019
Upheld - 8 hours OT
Pinder, Christopher
2019-0248-0009
2019-0143
03/07/2019
Upheld - 12 hours OT
Alkazely, Saleh
2017-0248-0018
2017-0485
04/22/2017
Dismissed
Brearley, Craig
2017-0248-0197
2017-2463
10/25/2017
Upheld - 12 hours OT
De Freitas, Ricky
2017-0248-0165
2017-2114
10/02/2017
Upheld - 12 hours OT
Devries, Melissa
2017-0248-0016
2017-0409
04/15/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0017
2017-0410
04/15/2017
Upheld in part – 8 hours OT
2017-0248-0190
2017-2387
10/08/2017
Upheld – 16 hours OT
2017-0248-0191
2017-2388
10/08/2017
Upheld – 16 hours OT
Dowling, Christopher
2017-0248-0185
2017-2134
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Escoto, Tayron
2016-0248-0040
2016-2167
11/08/2016
Upheld – 8 hours at straight time
Giovannangeli, Roberto
2017-0248-0008
2016-2763
02/10/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0006
2016-2761
02/21/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0003
2016-2566
01/24/2017
Dismissed
2016-0248-0041
2016-2245
12/16/2016
Dismissed
2016-0248-0033
2016-2070
11/24/2016
Dismissed
Heiliger, David
2016-0248-0034
2016-2071
11/24/2016
Upheld in part – 8 hours OT
2013-0248-0027
2013-2569
06/20/2013
Upheld – 8 hours OT
Jacobson, Steve
2016-0248-0009
2016-0465
04/29/2016
Dismissed
Lane, Trevor
2017-0248-0132
2017-1972
09/26/2017
Upheld – 12 hours OT
Leroux, Tim
2017-0248-0085
2017-1816
09/05/2017
Dismissed
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
MacDonald, Shaun
2016-0248-0029
2016-1913
11/11/2016
Upheld – 12 hours OT
McIlveen, Lynn
2017-0248-0009
2016-2764
02/10/2017
Dismissed
Muth, Peter
2016-0248-0035
2016-2072
11/23/2016
Dismissed
Neville, Kayne
2018-0248-0115
2018-0094
02/08/2018
Upheld - 4 hours at straight time; and applicable adjustment to CSD
Pracey, Tammy
2017-0248-0055
2017-1628
07/10/2017
Dismissed
Stathakos, Vrasidas
2017-0248-0146
2017-2044
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Tatryn, Todd
2017-0248-0193
2017-2446
10/25/2017
Dismissed
Al-Jalili, Ali
2017-0248-0046
2017-1443
07/29/2017
Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison
2017-0248-0180
2017-2129
10/02/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0181
2017-2130
10/02/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0107
2017-1853
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0081
2017-1812
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0064
2017-1770
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0065
2017-1771
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0066
2017-1772
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Borsatto, Sergio
2017-0248-0140
2017-1980
09/26/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0087
2017-1818
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Brearley, Craig
2017-0248-0351
2017-3122
12/06/2017
Dismissed
Champagne, Nicole
2018-0248-0023
2017-3650
01/13/2018
Allowed – 12 hours OT
2017-0248-0024
2017-1097
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Collins, Elizabeth
2017-0248-0031
2017-1262
06/30/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0025
2017-1098
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Creighton, Robert
2017-0248-0166
2017-2115
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Devries, Melissa
2017-0248-0239
2017-2621
10/08/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0223
2017-2515
10/25/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0192
2017-2389
10/08/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0189
2017-2386
10/08/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0111
2017-1857
09/05/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0015
2017-0408
04/15/2017
Dismissed
Edwards, Michael
2017-0248-0120
2017-1866
09/26/2017
Dismissed
Heiliger, David
2017-0248-0071
2017-1777
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Iacoviello, Paul
2017-0248-0032
2017-1395
07/25/2017
Dismissed
Jovic, Marko
2017-0248-0121
2017-1867
09/26/2017
Dismissed
Kearns, Steven
2017-0248-0023
2017-1096
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Kennedy, Kevin
2017-0248-0252
2017-2683
11/07/2017
Dismissed
Masson, Paul
2017-0248-0036
2017-1433
07/29/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0028
2017-1259
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Masson, Derek
2016-0248-0013
2016-0705
05/27/2016
Dismissed
McIlveen, Lynn
2017-0248-0225
2017-2517
10/25/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0063
2017-1769
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Mesaric, Sean
2017-0248-0029
2017-1260
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Penic, Michael
2017-0248-0026
2017-1238
06/30/2017
Dismissed
Pinder, Christopher
2017-0248-0322
2017-3077
12/06/2017
Allowed – 12 hours OT
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
Pollard, Philip
2009-0248-0043
2009-1954
09/29/2009
Allowed – 12 hours OT
Powell, David
2017-0248-0226
2017-2518
10/25/2017
Dismissed
Rodriguez, Walter
2017-0248-0104
2017-1835
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Shires, Bill
2017-0248-0061
2017-1767
09/19/2017
Dismissed
Spencer, Jason
2017-0248-0177
2017-2126
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Stathakos, Vrasidas
2017-0248-0187
2017-2136
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Tatryn, Todd
2017-0248-0109
2017-1855
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0108
2017-1854
09/19/2017
Dismissed
2016-0248-0025
2016-1601
09/13/2016
Dismissed
Jacobson, Steve
2017-0248-0172
2017-2121
10/02/2017
Dismissed
2017-0248-0147
2017-2045
10/02/2017
Dismissed
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
Moniz, Colin
2013-0234-0340
2013-2857
10/31/2013
Dismissed
Ranck, Kelly
2013-0234-0351
2013-3168
11/11/2013
Upheld – 12 hours STAT (double time)
Noble, Earle
2011-0234-0062
2011-0764
05/09/2011
Dismissed
2014-0234-0415
2014-3028
07/30/2014
Upheld – 12 hours OT
Pinneau, Wayne
2009-0582-0104
2009-1770
08/10/2009
Dismissed
2009-0582-0105
2009-1771
08/10/2009
Dismissed
Pinkney, Suzanne
2013-0108-0064
2013-1111
06/07/2013
Dismissed
Alaimo, Vince
2012-0248-0016
2012-0406
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison
2012-0248-0017
2012-0407
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Brearley, Craig
2012-0248-0018
2012-0408
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Buttenham, Brian
2012-0248-0019
2012-0409
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Devries, Melissa
2012-0248-0020
2012-0410
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Graham, Patricia
2012-0248-0021
2012-0411
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Gulka, Patrick
2012-0248-0022
2012-0412
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Jackson, Dennis
2012-0248-0023
2012-0413
03/06/2012
Dismissed
MacNeil, Laurie
2012-0248-0024
2012-0414
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Millen, Darcy
2012-0248-0026
2012-0416
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Sebele, Michele
2012-0248-0027
2012-0417
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Siguenza, William
2012-0248-0028
2012-0418
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Stavropoulos, Angela
2012-0248-0029
2012-0419
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Walker, Paul
2012-0248-0030
2012-0420
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Whyte, Thomas
2012-0248-0031
2012-0421
03/03/2012
Dismissed
Zizzo, Christopher
2012-0248-0032
2012-0422
03/03/2012
Dismissed
Alaimo, Vince
2012-0248-0034
2012-0268
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Beharrell, Allison
2012-0248-0035
2012-0269
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Brearley, Craig
2012-0248-0036
2012-0270
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Buttenham, Brian
2012-0248-0037
2012-0271
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Devries, Melissa
2012-0248-0038
2012-0272
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Graham, Patricia
2012-0248-0039
2012-0273
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Gulka, Patrick
2012-0248-0040
2012-0274
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Jackson, Dennis
2012-0248-0041
2012-0275
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
Maclean, Joyce
2012-0248-0043
2012-0277
03/05/2012
Dismissed
MacNeil, Laurie
2012-0248-0044
2012-0278
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Millen, Darcy
2012-0248-0046
2012-0280
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Saul, Lita
2012-0248-0047
2012-0281
03/08/2012
Dismissed
Sebele, Michele
2012-0248-0048
2012-0282
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Siguenza, William
2012-0248-0049
2012-0283
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Stavropoulos, Angela
2012-0248-0050
2012-0284
03/06/2012
Dismissed
Walker, Paul
2012-0248-0051
2012-0285
03/05/2012
Dismissed
Whyte, Thomas
2012-0248-0052
2012-0286
03/03/2012
Dismissed
Decambra, Jeffrey
2012-0582-0121
2012-0485
03/22/2012
Dismissed
Peacock, Daryl
2010-0582-0037
2010-1879
08/09/2010
Upheld – 12 hours OT
Brown, Linda
2009-0582-0095
2009-1777
10-Sep-09
Dismissed
Walterhouse, Christopher
2009-0582-0099
2009-1763
23-Jul-09
Dismissed
Grievor
OPSEU #
GSB #
Grievance Date
Outcome
Manna, Mark et al
2017-5112-0245
2017-2305
09/05/2017
Upheld – 8 hours OT to each grievor
Deyell, Robert
2007-0108-0036
2007-1381
07/25/2007
Dismissed
2007-0108-0037
2007-1382
07/25/2007
Dismissed
2008-0108-0083
2008-0520
04/29/2008
Upheld in Part – 8 hours OT
2008-0108-0099
2008-1138
06/14/2008
Upheld – 11 hours OT
2008-0108-0143
2008-3240
12/10/2008
Dismissed
2009-0108-0014
2008-4038
01/30/2009
Dismissed
2009-0108-0016
2008-4039
01/30/2009
Dismissed
2008-0108-0031
2007-3998
02/13/2008
Dismissed
2008-0108-0142
2008-3239
12/10/2008
Dismissed
2009-0108-0045
2009-1082
05/01/2009
Allowed – 7 hours OT
Guevarra, Krizzane
2015-5112-0231
2015-2610
11/14/2015
Allowed – 28 hours OT
Preyma, Mark
2018-5112-0149
2018-2191
09/05/2018
Allowed – 10 hours OT
2018-5112-0215
2018-3245
12/07/2018
Dismissed
Samuels, Jacqueline
2014-5112-0230
2014-3757
02/21/2014
Allowed – 12 hours straight time
Sunmola, Margaret
2015-5112-0223
2015-2602
11/24/2015
Dismissed
Walsh, James
2014-5112-0100
2014-2847
08/01/2014
Allowed – 48 hours OT
Zoldak, Jolanta
2018-5112-0207
2018-3106
11/15/2018
Dismissed