GSB#2008-1246
UNION#2008-0582-0167
Additional files attached in “Appendix “A”
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION
Under
THE CROWN EMPLOYEES COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ACT
Before
THE GRIEVANCE SETTLEMENT BOARD
BETWEEN
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
(Boudreau et al)
Union
- and -
The Crown in Right of Ontario
(Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services)
Employer
BEFORE
Felicity D. Briggs
Vice-Chair
FOR THE UNION
John Wardell and Dan Sidsworth
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
Grievance Officers
FOR THE EMPLOYER
Greg Gledhill
Treasury Board Secretariat
Centre for Employee Relations
Employee Relations Advisor
HEARING
November 29, 2016
Decision
1In April of 2011, the parties signed a Memorandum of Agreement for the Med/Arb process within this Ministry. In that agreement it was agreed that overtime grievances would be dealt with on a regular basis at every institution. It was the stated expectation that the parties would “move forward together in a timely manner to resolve as many outstanding overtime grievances” as possible at each institution. Monthly meetings were to be scheduled for this purpose. It was hoped that these monthly overtime grievance sessions would resolve most grievances.
2It was also agreed in the Memorandum that Med-Arb sessions would be held to deal exclusively with overtime grievances from time to time. The parties would meet to attempt resolution of the outstanding grievances and the remaining disputes would be put before this Board.
3In May of 2012 the first decision from this process was issued. As agreed by the parties, that decision was without prejudice and without reasons. Since that time a number of sessions have been held and various decisions rendered. The process has not been altered and continues to serve the parties well.
4The most recent overtime disputes were dealt with on August 17th & 18th, September 15th, November 9th, 10th and 29th, 2016. Overtime grievances were filed by Correctional Officers from Elgin Middlesex Detention Centre, Central East Correctional Centre, Toronto East Detention Centre, Maplehurst Correctional Complex, Niagara Detention Centre, Quinte Detention Centre and North Bay Jail.
5Both parties presented facts, supporting documents and made submissions regarding the various disputes. Attached as Appendix A is the list of grievances and the disposition of this Board. Any monies that are owing to individual grievors as set out in the attached are to be paid at the appropriate overtime rate less statutory deductions.
6I remain seized.
Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 23rd day of January 2017.
Appendix “A”
Grievor
GSB Number
OPSEU File Number
Results
Boudreau, Barbara A
2008-1340
2008-0582-0250
Dismissed
Boudreau, Barbara A
2008-1341
2008-0582-0251
Dismissed
Boudreau, Barbara A
2008-1343
2008-0582-0253
Dismissed
Brown, Linda
2009-1778
2009-0582-0096
Upheld - 4 Hours @ Dbl Time
Coughlin, Shelley D
2009-2238
2009-0582-0121
Dismissed
Pratt, Anne M
2010-1263
2010-0108-0040
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Hayford, Tammy
2011-0538
2011-0368-0030
Dismissed
Sutherland. Angela
2011-2329
2011-0616-0020
Dismissed
Walsh, Lindsay M
2011-2944
2011-0467-0020
Dismissed
Smith, Eric James
2012-0190
2012-0108-0037
Dismissed
Ochocinski, Alicia
2012-0195
2012-0234-0045
Dismissed
Saucier, Amanda
2012-0224
2012-0616-0013
Dismissed
Louwe, Andrea Katherine
2012-0264
2012-0108-0042
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
McCallum, Glenanne
2012-0265
2012-0108-0043
Upheld - 8 Hours @ Dbl Time
Richard, Jeff
2012-0550
2012-0616-0015
Dismissed
Saunders, Chantel Cecile
2012-0917
2012-0368-0066
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Allin, Robert
2012-1158
2012-0368-0077
Dismissed
Smith, Tracey A
2012-1279
2012-0108-0092
Dismissed
Thomson, Sandra D
2012-2274
2012-0108-0137
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Hutton, Iain
2012-2566
2011-0368-0251
Upheld - 12 Hours Dbl Time
Dunn, Sean
2012-2952
2012-0368-0157
Dismissed
Surowiec, David
2012-4744
2013-0368-0027
Dismissed
Surowiec, David
2012-4749
2013-0368-0032
Dismissed
Walterhouse, Christopher S
2013-0609
2013-0582-0016
Dismissed
Dallinger, Richard A
2013-0741
2013-0368-0057
Dismissed
Beetham, Shane
2013-0814
2013-0582-0022
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Vel, Robert
2013-2619
2013-0108-0113
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Speller, Ryan
2013-3142
2013-0108-0129
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Sutherland, Steve
2013-3308
2013-0616-0042
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Hopper, Dale
2013-3443
2013-0108-0138
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Baker, Joshua James
2013-3445
2013-0108-0140
Dismissed
Speller, Ryan
2013-3446
2013-0108-0141
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Warburton, Vicky
2014-1054
2014-0368-0079
Dismissed
Pratt, Anne
2014-2501
2014-0108-0034
Dismissed
Butsch, Chris
2014-2524
2014-0368-0146
Dismissed
Dunn, Sean
2014-2783
2014-0368-0160
Dismissed
Grievor
GSB Number
OPSEU File Number
Results
Butsch, Chris
2014-2782
2014-0368-0159
Dismissed
Rimos, Alex
2014-2795
2014-0582-0038
Upheld - 4 Hours Part
Shipticki, Theresa
2014-2881
2014-0582-0040
Dismissed
Barrera, Anthony
2014-2882
2014-0582-0041
Dismissed
Landry, Chris
2014-3131
2014-0368-0168
Dismissed
Brooks, David
2014-3133
2014-0368-0170
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Kaiserling, Jenny
2014-3755
2014-0582-0044
Dismissed
Narhi, Roger
2014-4506
2013-0252-0034
Dismissed
Rimos, Alex
2014-4749
2014-0582-0056
Upheld - 8 Hours Part
Narhi, Roger
2014-4754
2015-0252-0003
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Wurtz, Valerie
2014-4762
2015-0582-0005
Dismissed
Allin, Robert
2014-5039
2015-0368-0337
August 6 - Upheld - 12 Hours OT August 11 - Dismissed
Murphy, Caroline
2014-5040
2015-0368-0087
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Ostapeck, Robert
2014-5046
2015-0368-0093
Upheld - 4 Hours Straight Time Upheld - 8 Hours OT and CSD to reflect 40 Hours for the wk
Kanter, Stewart
2015-0104
2015-0368-0100
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Mizon, Joanne
2015-0489
2015-0108-0009
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Hengeveld, Neil
2015-0842
2015-0467-0011
Dismissed
Manlow, Adam
2015-1227
2015-0467-0015
Dismissed
Hutton, Iain
2015-1246
2015-0368-0280
Dismissed
Matthews, Currie
2015-1351
2015-0368-0298
Dismissed
Butsch, Chris
2015-1371
2015-0368-0299
Dismissed
Saunders, Daniel
2015-1499
2015-0368-0307
Dismissed
Sullivan, Karen
2015-1504
2015-0368-0315
Dismissed
Kivisaari, Krista
2015-1505
2015-0368-0316
Dismissed
Doran, Kendra
2015-1507
2015-0467-0016
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Cook, Tim
2015-1872
2015-0368-0334
Upheld - 4 Hours OT
Knight, Carol
2015-1941
2015-0616-0043
Dismissed
Knight, Carol
2015-1942
2015-0616-0044
Dismissed
Sampson, Richard
2015-2035
2015-0234-0156
Dismissed
Pastien, Marcella
2015-2212
2015-0467-0019
Dismissed
Rimos, Alex
2015-2255
2015-0582-0031
Dismissed
Veenstra, Trevor
2010-1235
2010-0467-0007
Upheld - 12 Hours Straight Time
Vriesema, Daniel
2015-2456
2015-0467-0025
Dismissed
Deschamps, Sophie
2015-2856
2016-0467-0001
Upheld - 1 Hour Straight Time &
11 Hours OT & CSD changed at reflect 40 hrs work wk for Aug 31 - Sept 6
Deschamps, Sophie
2015-2857
2016-0467-0002
Upheld - 1 Hour Straight Time & 11 Hours OT & CSD changed at reflect 40 hrs work week for Aug 31 - Sept 6
Grievor
GSB Number
OPSEU File Number
Results
Boughen, Susan
2015-3004
2015-0368-0387
Dismissed
Kidd, Brad
2015-3288
2015-0582-0040
Dismissed
Brandy, Kevin
2016-0046
2016-0252-0003
Upheld - 24 Hours OT
Harnden, Colleen
2016-0424
2016-0368-0059
Upheld - 8 Hours OT
Sutherland. Angela
2016-0458
2015-0616-0061
Upheld - 4 Hours OT
Saucier, Amanda
2016-0460
2015-0616-0063
Dismissed
Wilms, Brian
2016-0468
2016-0368-0068
Upheld - 12 Hours Straight Time
Jubinville, Eric
2016-0470
2016-0616-0002
Dismissed
Morgan, Amanda
2016-0569
2016-0368-0081
Upheld - 12 Hours OT
Nanai, Ildiko
2016-0570
2016-0368-0082
Dismissed
Leveck, Tracey
2016-0708
2016-0368-0083
Dismissed
Aiabens, Kevin
2016-0710
2016-0368-0085
Dismissed
Aiabens, Kevin
2016-0711
2016-0368-0086
Dismissed
Dance, Jennifer
2016-0726
2016-0467-0009
Upheld - 4 Hours OT
Katsilieris, Andreas
2016-1045
2016-0234-0145
Dismissed