CITATION: Algarawi v. Berger, 2023 ONSC 5087
DIVISIONAL COURT FILE NO.: 23-272- ML
DATE: 20230915
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE – ONTARIO
DIVISIONAL COURT
RE: NORA HAIDER ALI ALGARAWI, a minor by her Litigation Guardian, SAKINA MAHAMAT TAHA, SAKINA MAHAMAT TAHA, personally, and ALI HAIDER ALGARAWI, Plaintiffs/Moving Party
AND:
DR. HOWARD BERGER, DR. ADELMO EDUARDO MARTOGLIO, DR. LAUREN HILARY JAIN, DR. MEGHAN LOUISE YVONNE BROWN, DR. YAEL GANOR PAZ, DR. FILOMENA MARY MEFFE, DR. J. DOE #1, DR. J. DOE #2, NURSE KATHLEEN LINDSAY, NURSE PAULA PATRICIA MALCOLM WALKER, NURSE YASITHRA YASSODARAN, NURSE A. WILLIAMS, NURSE A. CARR, NURSE M. LIN, NURSE J. DOE #1, NURSE J. DOE #2, NURSE J. DOE #3 and UNITY HEALTH TORONTO Defendants/Responding Parties
DIVISIONAL COURT FILE NO.: 23-273- ML
HEZEKIAH OBADIAH PORTER, a minor by his Litigation Guardian, CRAIG DERRICK PORTER, CRAIG DERRICK PORTER, personally, and SHERYL ANNAKIE PORTER, Plaintiffs/Moving Party
AND:
DR. MARILYN SUTANDAR, DR. RAMADAN ELMAHDY ELSUGY, DR. GEORGE VIRICH, DR. MAY IBRAHIM EL HAJJ, NURSE LAUREN PRENDERGAST, NURSE SIMONE REID, NURSE AMIE ARCHIBALD-VARLEY, NURSE KE XIN LI, NURSE AVALIN DOUGLAS, NURSE JESSICA MACGREGOR, NURSE ZERIDAH NATTIMBA and WILLIAM OSLER HEALTH SYSTEM Defendants/Moving Parties
BEFORE: Backhouse, Sheard and Gomery JJ.
COUNSEL: Mahsa Dabirian and Ryan Marinacci, for the Plaintiffs/Moving Party
Adam Goldenberg and Leah Ostler and Kate Martini, for the Defendants/Responding Parties, Dr. Howard Berger, Dr. Adelmo Eduardo Martoglio, Dr. Lauren Hilary Jain, Dr. Meghan Louise Yvonne Brown, Dr. Yael Ganor Paz Dr. Filomena Mary Meffe, Dr. Marilyn Sutandar, Dr. Ramadan Elmahdy Elsugy, Dr. George Virich, Dr. May Ibrahim El Hajj
Keegan Boyd and Henry Ngan, Lawyers for the Defendants/Responding Parties, Nurse Kathleen Lindsay, Nurse Paula Patricia Malcolm Walker, Nurse Yasithra Yassodaran, Nurse A. Williams, Nurse A. Carr, Unity Health Toronto, Nurse M. Lin, Nurse Lauren Prendergast, Nurse Simone Reid, Nurse Amie Archibald-Varley, Nurse Ke Xin Li, Nurse Avalin Douglas, Nurse Jessica Macgregor, Nurse Zeridah Nattimba and William Osler Health System
HEARD: in writing
ENDORSEMENT
[1] The motion for leave to appeal the order of Centa J., dated April 17, 2023 is dismissed with costs to the Responding Parties in the amount of $5000.
Backhouse J.
Sheard J.
Gomery J.
Released: September 15, 2023