The accused, Michael Toussaint and Felicia Chapman, were tried together on multiple counts of gasoline theft and possession of stolen license plates.
The Crown relied on affidavit evidence from gas station managers and video surveillance showing heavy-set black individuals driving Nissan Altimas with stolen plates stealing gas.
The court admitted the similar fact evidence across counts due to striking similarities in the perpetrators' physical characteristics, clothing, vehicles, and methods.
Relying on circumstantial evidence, including the accused's possession of identical vehicles and the stolen plates, the court found both accused guilty of almost all charges, concluding there was no reasonable possibility of innocence.