Lawrence A. Elliot

Following the dismissal of the plaintiff's summary judgment motion regarding a commercial lease and parking dispute, the successful defendant sought costs of $586,141.79 on a substantial indemnity scale.

The court declined to award substantial indemnity costs, finding the plaintiff's conduct was not reprehensible and noting that Rule 49.10 limits a defendant to partial indemnity costs even when the plaintiff's claim is completely dismissed.

The court awarded the defendant costs of $398,000 on a partial indemnity basis, finding the time spent and hourly rates reasonable given the complexity and the $4.6 million claim.

Following a trial on liability for a motor vehicle accident where the deceased driver was found 80% responsible and the City of Ottawa and its bus driver 20% responsible, the court determined the costs payable to the successful plaintiffs.

The plaintiffs sought over $811,000 in costs and disbursements.

The court reviewed the factors under Rule 57.01, including proportionality, the complexity of the case, and the results achieved.

The court reduced the plaintiffs' claimed costs due to excessive hourly rates for students/paralegals, duplication of effort, and excessive time spent on certain stages.

The court awarded the plaintiffs $527,065.25 in fees and $143,531.25 in disbursements.

Additionally, the court granted a Sanderson Order requiring the unsuccessful defendants to pay the costs of the successful defendant insurer directly.