John Leslie

Following the vacating of an ex parte order due to an exclusive jurisdiction clause, the respondent sought costs of the motion.

The court awarded costs on a partial indemnity basis, declining to award a higher scale as the applicant's conduct was not reprehensible.

The court allowed recovery for the value of work performed by the respondent's US counsel in drafting affidavits, noting that while foreign counsel cannot charge legal fees in Ontario, a fair and reasonable amount for the preparation work should be indemnified to avoid a windfall to the applicant.

Costs were fixed at $80,000 all-inclusive.

The plaintiff bank moved for summary judgment against the defendant guarantor for the balance owing on commercial loans.

The defendant argued that the bank's receiver sold the mortgaged property improvidently, thereby raising a genuine issue for trial.

The court found that the receiver took reasonable precautions to obtain the true market value of the property, including obtaining an appraisal and listing it on the MLS for a reasonable period.

The court concluded there was no genuine issue requiring a trial and granted summary judgment to the bank.