Heather Susan McIntyre

The Crown sought to have Brian Morgan-Baylis declared a dangerous offender following his conviction for aggravated assault, assault with a weapon, uttering threats, and counselling to commit suicide.

The court found Morgan-Baylis to be a dangerous offender under all three subsections of s. 753(1)(a) of the Criminal Code, citing a pattern of repetitive and persistent aggressive behaviour, a failure to restrain his conduct, and the brutal nature of the predicate offences.

Despite the Crown's request for an indeterminate sentence, the court imposed a determinate sentence of 6 years 4 months (after enhanced pre-sentence custody credit) followed by a 10-year Long-Term Supervision Order, concluding that this composite sentence, coupled with robust programming and strict conditions, offered a reasonable expectation of public protection.

The accused was sentenced for animal cruelty resulting in death.

During a domestic dispute with his girlfriend, the accused threw his 12-week-old German Shepherd puppy out a door and down stairs, then chased and slammed it to the ground, causing fatal injuries.

The court imposed an eight-month custodial sentence (less 68 days pre-sentence custody), a ten-year animal ownership prohibition, and a two-year probation order with conditions including community service, substance abuse counselling, and restrictions on association with witnesses.